The return of advertising craft—and why dumb can be a smart strategy

Mike Sutherland and Ant Nelson of adam&eve\TBWA discuss their favorite work, how they’ve been using AI and how to be a better creative. (adam&eve\TBWA)

In their continuing coverage of the 10 Questions series, AdAge interviewed two renowned creative directors. I enjoyed reading it and wanted to share. Enjoy!

Mike Sutherland and Ant Nelson have been creative partners for nearly three decades, having met at Doncaster College in 1997. Since then, they’ve built one of the industry’s most decorated partnerships, working at agencies including Saatchi & Saatchi, Fallon, Publicis New York and AMV BBDO before joining adam&eveDDB in 2017.

The pair were promoted to joint chief creative officers of adam&eveDDB in early 2025 and now hold those same roles at adam&eve\TBWA, formed through the merger of adam&eveDDB and TBWA\London. Over the years, they’ve helped create memorable work for brands including John Lewis, PlayStation, Volkswagen and CALM, the mental health charity behind the acclaimed “The Last Photo” campaign. In 2023, they were named Ad Age’s Creative Directors of the Year.

More recently, they’ve overseen work for Disney and Columbia Sportswear, including the latter’s irreverent “Engineered for Whatever” campaign. Their latest Columbia campaign, “Don’t Panic Room,” takes aim at tech billionaires preparing for the apocalypse by offering an off-grid survival bunker to someone who can show they could survive in the wild without one.

We spoke with Mike and Ant for our 10 Questions series, where we discussed the enduring appeal of classic Guinness and Stella Artois ads, why seemingly stupid ideas can be brilliant for business, their enthusiasm for the resurgence of craft and Mike’s fear of pigeons.


Mike and Ant, tell us … your first job in advertising, and your current job.

Mike Sutherland: I started my advertising life as a junior copywriter at Saatchi & Saatchi London. I’m currently joint CCO at adam&eve\TBWA.

Ant Nelson: Junior creative at Saatchi & Saatchi. Joint chief creative officer at adam&eve\TBWA.

An ad or campaign that inspired you coming up in the business.

Mike: Guinness “Surfer.” I remember seeing it for the first time. I was 22 years old and had just got a job in advertising. I thought it was the coolest thing I had ever seen. Still do.

Ant: The Stella Artois “Reassuringly Expensive” campaign. The quality of work that was written in the late ’90s to mid-2000s was incredible and a real inspiration for me when I first started out in the business. The craft that went into every single one of those spots was first class. The storytelling, the direction, the cinematography, the casting, the music—it was just amazing. I can’t think of a better body of work to this day.

The last ad or campaign you really enjoyed.

Mike: I really like the Coinbase “Your Way Out” spot. Great idea, great production, great craft, great track … it has it all. The more you watch it, the more you enjoy it.

Ant: The Claude Super Bowl campaign “A Time and a Place,” which came out of Mother London. I love it for many reasons, one of which is that it’s a proper campaign. There are very few brands producing campaigns anymore, and here we have four excellent, highly entertaining commercials that are impossible to ignore and the writing is second to none.

A recent project you’re proud of.

Mike: The work that the agency has been doing with Disney. It’s such an iconic brand to work on, and our latest holiday spot is about to be released. The Disney clients are fantastic and we share the same belief that emotional storytelling is the most powerful storytelling.

Ant: “Don’t Panic Room,” the latest campaign that we’ve just made for Columbia Sportswear. Last time we targeted Flat Earthers for “Expedition Impossible.” This time it’s the tech bros. The AI founders who are building themselves bunkers in case the worst happens. Well, this bunker’s heading to someone with the survival skills to start all over again, if the world really does go to shit.

No Panic Room

One thing that can make anyone a better creative.

Mike: Love what you do and be obsessive about it. Study the work that wins. Not just recently but go back through the years. Use it as inspiration. It doesn’t take long for great work to inspire more great work.

Ant: Before putting pen to paper, get to know the business problem that you’re trying to solve. As a creative, it’s easy to focus purely on the proposition that’s written on the brief, without fully understanding the problem at hand.

A trend or theme you’re enjoying in advertising right now.

Mike: I love that craft is back in a big way. Despite all the advances in AI, it’s brilliant to see big brands choosing to make work that proudly shows off the skills of human art and craft. The recent work from Apple and Coinbase are just a few examples of this. Long may it continue.

Ant: Participation. Over the past few years there seems to have been a real shift from brands talking at consumers to brands actively involving consumers within their comms.

How you’ve been using AI lately.

Mike: I made a video of our pet beagle swimming with dolphins. My 8-year-old daughter asked me what AI can do, so we decided to use it to make something. It was brilliant to see her reaction to an idea inside her head that suddenly came to life right in front of her eyes. As an agency, we’ve been using AI more and more as an indispensable tool for bringing ideas to life in ways we never could before.

Ant: I’d like to tell you, but it’s changing so quickly that by the time this is published it will seem old hat.

What most brands still don’t understand about creativity.

Mike: Push creativity in the right direction and it can be one of the most powerful tools available. Push creativity in the wrong direction and it can be a bit of a damp squib.

Ant: That sometimes the most stupid creative idea can be the best business idea. An idea which can easily be dismissed and deemed as stupid can actually be the most disruptive and distinctive thing that can elevate a brand. Sometimes playing it safe is the most dangerous thing to do.

Something people might not know about you.

Mike: I hate pigeons. They scare the crap out of me.

Ant: I wrote my very first advertising campaign when I was 11 years old. It was an anti-graffiti campaign and it ran for two years.

Where advertising is headed next.

Mike: Who knows? And that’s what’s so exciting about it. With all the advances in tech, the possibilities of what can and can’t be done are changing every day. Literally.

Ant: Who knows? But I can’t wait to find out.

Well, there you have it. The future of advertising? Hmmm, it’ll change by tomorrow and the next day and the next and so on. You get the idea; it’s fast-paced and challenging and always changing.

Stay tuned!

Hopefully making a ruckus, one blog post at a time!

Be sure to check out my other blog,Joe’s Journey, for selected short stories and personal insights on life and its detours.

Leave a Reply